Go google “best gun for survival” and as of today you get 30,600,000 returns. The argument goes something like this…
GunGuy1:”The best gun in the entire world is x”
GunGuy2: makes valid point about gun x that it may not be the best but is still a good gun:
GunGuy1:”WHat ar you Hitlers! you must be retard or SOmething!!!1!!11!!”
This conversation goes back and forth for way to long.
I do not believe in the best of anything. Can you imagine the best screwdriver? A gun is a tool. It is a very specific tool with millions of permutations. There is no such gun that is perfect for everything. Let’s look at different guns and see what they have to offer.
When you really want to reach out and touch something, this is what you want. In a prolonged disaster situation, food becomes a priority. A .30-06 or 7mm bolt action with a scope will bring home dinner. Lighter calibers like the .30-30 offer similar game getting capabilities but with less recoil. A lever action .30-30 would offer the advantage of quick shooting in a defensive situation. Hitting game at 300 yards and hitting people at 300 yards are two different stories. Defending a house in an urban setting would be an area the hunting rifle may fall short. A situation that requires you to shelter in place and defend your home from multiple aggressors would require faster shooting and lighter loads. An advantage of hunting rifles is the popularity of the cartridge. In a prolonged disaster situation ammunition stocks may run low. The popularity of these cartridges in North America would increase your odds of coming across more should your own supplies dwindle.
Everybody loves machine guns. It’s a fact. Britain conquered the world using single shot muzzle loading muskets. I remember watching Zulu Dawn and thinking, “If the redcoats had some AK’s that would have been way easier.” This exposition will only cover two rifles: the AK and the AR. Please don’t get sad that I don’t cover your favorite assault rifle. This is to discuss two very popular rifles in America right now. The AK-47 is the most used assault rifle on the planet. It has fought in conflicts of every imaginable terrain, climate, and scale and repeatedly proved its worth. It’s so simple you can train an illiterate goat-herder from Central Asia to use it in 5 minutes. The 7.62 x 39 is heavy enough to drop attackers quickly and can even drop medium sized game within distance. I live in a suburban environment and envision a shelter in place scenario. When the food where I live runs out, I don’t need to be shooting anything beyond 100 yards. I’ll be dealing with looters or foragers. I want a nice, reliable, fast gun that will keep my home protected. A drawback to the AK vs the AR is the range. Sure, you can make it into a Druganov clone to increase the accuracy but the load is too light to take anything bigger than mule deer. The AR (and its descendents) is an exceptional rifle that offers the rapid fire needed in a close quarter urban environment. The low muzzle velocity and high energy create startling wound profiles on game and hostiles alike. The AR has been fielded in multiple environments and come up shy on just one facet, reliability. AR’s are built with extremely tight tolerances. These tolerances allow the AR to put rounds on target well past 700 yards. This also proves to be its downfall when operating in dirty, grimy conditions. Jamming in the middle of a gunfight sounds like no fun. If you found an AR and an AK in a mud puddle filled with sand you have two options. Pick up the AR, field strip it, clean every nook and cranny and hope it works. Or you could pick up the AK, urinate in the action, cycle it a few times and be ready to party. A definite advantage of the AR over the AK is its modularity. I’ve heard it called Barbie for boys. Every imaginable pistol grip, stock, magazine, scope, and doo dad can be mounted on the AR to fit the owners needs. An AR also has the advantage of using the 5.56 NATO round. This could be an advantage if the disaster takes the shape of some blue bonnets coming over our hills.
It takes big game. It takes small game. It takes birds. It takes aggressors without even aiming. The shotgun is definitely a tool I want to have if the SHTF. The same gun can be used for multiple purposes depending on the ammunition. Light loads for the daily small game and birds it would take to maintain calories, slugs for the occasional big game. I would argue pump over auto for simplicity sake. I can fix my Remington 870 Express but my brother’s Benelli is like a rubix cube. Even if you get stuck with a basement full of cheap target loads you can make cut shells. The shotgun may be great for all sorts of situations but its range may leave something to be desired. Anything beyond 100 yards will merely be irritated by the noise of the gun and remain injury free.
Hear me out. My Model 1851 Confederate Navy .44 is deadly. I take squirrel and rabbit with it easily. I can use up black powder on small game before dipping into any “real” ammo. It’s a cheap and easy way to prolong the home magazine. What about caps? Those will run out before the powder surely?. To that I say Ha! Flintlock! And I also say don’t call me Shirley. Our forefathers defeated the largest army in the world using flintlocks. The Zulu’s may have smashed the British at Islandlwana but we started the tradition of whipping her majesty’s soldiers way before they did.
100% necessary. A large caliber handgun such as the .44 magnum or a Desert Eagle .50 will easily take large animals within range. A handgun is also essential when it comes to self-defense. The abundance of handgun ammunition will ensure supplies last if the SHTF. Handguns do not have anything near the power or range of the other guns listed here. A handgun is certainly something you want to have in the toolkit if things get ugly. I would again argue revolver over automatic for simplicity. The revolver certainly falls short in the capacity department when compared to semi-autos.
So what are we going to do? There are several things at play here but for me a chief concern is price. My Scottish blood turns to ice when I look at the prices of guns and ammunition. The reason I’m such an AK fanboy has two reasons, durability and price. I may be planning for the apocalypse but I still have bills to pay right now. An AK-47 in America should cost $400 with two magazines and a cleaning kit, new in cosmoline. An AR will be double that. For a rifle you can get a .30-06 bolt action for $200 (minus scope). How about a Nagant? You can equip your whole family with the same rifle Simo Häyhä used for $600! A shotgun will run anywhere from $80 for a single shot .410 up into the $300’s for a good pump action. What about the price of ammo? Shotgun shells can be accumulated in larger amounts for a lower price than rifle ammo. Consider the cost saving of having your weapons be of a uniform caliber. Think pistol caliber rifles combined with handguns of the same caliber. A .40 carbine with a .40 on your hip will provide several methods to eat food and deter people with ill intent. Black powder is crazy cheap. You can melt down anything metal for bullets and shoot for eons. If you want to get creative you can even make black powder from scavenged resources.
So what then is the best gun to have if things got really, really, bad?If you haven’t seen the light yet let me help you. If you got through the first paragraph and said ‘tldr’ here’s a picture instead of words.